Chapter 56 of 17th & 18th edition

Back Up Next

Answers to Unsolved Practical Examples in ‘Indirect Taxes'

Question 1 Compute the Customs duty liability as per the provisions of the Customs Act, 1962, from the following information. Make suitable assumptions and indicate the same in your answer: Product Imported - ‘X’ Total FOB Value of the goods - US $ 74000 Quantity Imported - 100 MTs. Ocean freight - US $ 10000 Insurance - US $ 740 Landing charges - 1% of CIF value Exchange rate - 1 US $ = Rs. 37 Date of presentation of Bill of Entry - 28.02.2002 Date of Entry Inwards of the Vessel - 03.03.2002 - . - . - . - . - . - Customs duty Rates on 28-2-2002 - (i) Basic Customs Duty 25% (ii) Education Cess - 2% (iii) Countervailing Duty (Additional Duty) 12%. - . - . - Customs duty rates on 3.3.2002 - (i) Basic Customs Duty 20% (ii) Education Cess 2% (iii) Countervailing Duty (Additional Duty) 8%.Special CVD under section 3(5) of Customs Tariff Act is applicable. How much Cenvat can be availed by importer, if he is manufacturer. - . - . - . - Will your answer change if the actual cost of Freight and Insurance is not available ? (ICWA Inter - December 1997).

Answer 1 – Though Bill of Entry was presented earlier, entry inward was granted later. Hence, rate relevant will be as on 3.3.2002 i.e. Basic 20%, Special CVD 4% and CVD 8%.

FOB Price US $ 74,000
Add – Ocean Freight US $ 10,000
Add – Insurance charges US $      740
Total CIF Price US $ 84,740
CIF @ Rs 37 = 1 US $ Rs 31,35,380.00
Add – Landing charges @ 1% Rs 31,353.80
Assessable Value Rs 31,66,733.80

 

Calculation of duty payable is as follows -       
  Duty Rate % Amount Rs Duty Rs
 (A) Assessable Value Rs   3,166,733.80  
 (B) Customs Duty 20   633,346.76
 (C) Sub-total for calculating CVD (A+B)   3,800,080.56  
 (D) CVD as % of C 8   304,006.44
 (E) Education cess of excise - 2% of 'D' 2   6,080.13
 (F) Sub-total for calculating Edu Cess (B+D+E)   943,433.33  
 (G) Education Cess of Customs (2% of 'F') 2   18,868.67
 (H) Sub-total for Special CVD (C+D+E+G)   4,129,035.80  
 (I) Special CVD (4% of 'H') 4   165,161.43
 (J) Total Duty Rs B+D+E+G     1,127,463.43
 (K) Total duty (rounded)     1,127,463.00

If actual cost of freight and insurance is not available, it should be taken as 20% of FOB and 1.125% of FOB respectively. Hence, freight will have to be taken as US $ 14,800 and insurance as US $ 832.50. Thus, CIF value will be US $ 89,632.50. Student can calculate customs duty payable on that basis.

A manufacturer can avail Cenvat credit of duty as specified in columns D (i.e. CVD), E (education cess of excise) and I i.e. Spl CVD.

Question 2 Compute (keeping in mind the provisions of the Customs Act, 1962 and Customs Tariff Act, 1975), the total customs duty payable by an importer on goods ‘X’ imported by sea into India, from the following details. You may, wherever appropriate, make suitable assumptions, indicating the same in your answer. - * Value of Goods (FOB) $ 1,000 (Dollars) * Weight of Goods 1,000 Kg * Freight Charges $ 100 (Dollars) * Insurance Charges $ 20 (Dollars) * Handling Charges Rs. 200 * Exchange Rate 4 Dollars = Rs. 100 * Date of Presentation of Bill of Entry - 4.5.2005 * Date of Entry Inwards of Vessel - 1.5.2005 Rates of Customs Duty on 1.5.2005 - * Basic 20% Adv. * Education Cess -2% * Additional (CVD) 15%. * Rates of Customs Duty on 4.5.2005 - * Basic 15% Adv. * Education cess -2%* Additional (CVD) 16%. - . - Note : Special CVD under section 3(5) of Customs Tariff Act is applicable. No other particulars are relevant. How much Cenvat can be availed by importer, if he is manufacturer (CA Final - November 1996 adopted).

Answer 2 - CIF Value is US $ 1,120 [1,000 + 100 + 20]. In Rupees, it will be Rs 28,000 @ Rs 25 per dollar. Add handling charges of Rs 200. [It is presumed that these are ‘landing charges’ and hence separate landing charges are not added]. Thus, Customs Value (Assessable Value) is Rs 28,200.

  Duty Rate % Amount Rs Duty Rs
 (A) Assessable Value Rs   28,200.00  
 (B) Customs Duty 15   4,230.00
 (C) Sub-total for calculating CVD (A+B)   32,430.00  
 (D) CVD as % of C 16   5,188.80
 (E) Education cess of excise - 2% of 'D' 2   103.78
 (F) Sub-total for calculating Edu Cess (B+D+E)   9,522.58  
 (G) Education Cess of Customs (2% of 'F') 2   190.45
 (H) Sub-total for Special CVD (C+D+E+G)   37,913.03  
 (I) Special CVD (4% of 'H') 4   1,516.52
 (J) Total Duty Rs B+D+E+G     11,229.55
 (K) Total duty (rounded)     11,230.00

A manufacturer can avail Cenvat credit of duty as specified in columns D (i.e. CVD), E (education cess of excise) and I i.e. Spl CVD.

Question 3 Some spares were imported by air from Germany at CIF value of 1,200 DM, which included air freight of 380 DM and insurance charges of 20 DM. If exchange rate is 23.40 Rs. = 1 DM, find the Customs Value. Rate of customs duty is 20%, and education cess is 2%. Excise duty chargeable on similar goods in India is 16% as per tariff rate. However, as per an exemption notification, the effective rate of excise duty is 8%. Special CVD under section 3(5) of Customs Tariff Act is applicable. Find the customs duty payable. How much Cenvat can be availed by importer, if he is manufacturer.

Answer 3 – Since actual freight exceeds 20%, it has to be limited to 20% for valuation. Now, FOB Value is DM 800 [CIF – Freight – Insurance]. Add freight DM 160 [20% of DM 800] and insurance DM 20 [Actual]. Thus, CIF price for valuation purposes is DM 980/-. Convert in Rs @ Rs 23.40 = 1 DM. Thus, CIF in Rs is 22,932.00. Add 1% landing charges (Rs 229.32) to get Assessable Value of Rs 23,161.32.

Calculation of duty payable is as follows -       
  Duty Rate % Amount Rs Duty Rs
 (A) Assessable Value Rs   23,161.32  
 (B) Customs Duty 20   4,632.26
 (C) Sub-total for calculating CVD (A+B)   27,793.58  
 (D) CVD as % of C 8   2,223.49
 (E) Education cess of excise - 2% of 'D' 2   44.47
 (F) Sub-total for calculating Edu Cess (B+D+E)   6,900.22  
 (G) Education Cess of Customs (2% of 'F') 2   138.00
 (H) Sub-total for Special CVD (C+D+E+G)   30,199.54  
 (I) Special CVD (4% of 'H') 4   1,207.98
 (J) Total Duty Rs B+D+E+G     8,246.20
 (K) Total duty (rounded)     8,246.00

 

A manufacturer can avail Cenvat credit of duty as specified in columns D (i.e. CVD), E (education cess of excise) and I i.e. Spl CVD.

Question 4 An importer has imported a machine from Japan at FOB cost of 9,00,000 Yens. Other details are as follows :

(a) Freight from Japan to Indian port was 18,000 Yens.

(b) Transit insurance charges were 1% of FOB value.

(c) Design and development charges of 90,000 Yens were paid to a consultancy firm in Japan for design of machinery.

(d) Packing charges of 22,000 Yen were charged extra.

(e) Rs. 20,000 were spent in design cost on machine in India.

(f) An amount of 98,500 Yen was payable to Japanese manufacturer towards charges for installation and commissioning the machine in India.

(g) Rate of exchange as announced by RBI was : 1 yen = Rs. 0.309

(h) Rate of exchange as announced by Central Government by notification under section 14 (3) (a) (i) : 1 Yen = 0.302 Rs

(i) Customs duty was 20% and education cess was 2%. Excise duty on similar machinery in India would be 16%. Special CVD under section 3(5) of Customs Tariff Act is applicable.

Find the customs duty payable. How much Cenvat can be availed by importer, if he is manufacturer.

Answer 4 – Design charges of Rs 20,000 are not includible in Assessable Value, but design charges paid abroad are includible. Erection and commissioning charges are not includible. Relevant rate of exchange is 1 Yen = Rs 0.302. Hence, duty payable is calculated as follows -

FOB Price Yen 9,00,000
Add – Ocean Freight Yen 18,000
Add – Insurance charges Yen 9,000
Add - Design and consultancy charges Yen 90,000
Add –Packing Charges Yen     22,000
Total CIF Price Yen 10,39,000
CIF @ Rs 0.302 = 1 Yen Rs 3,13,778.00
Add – Landing charges @ 1% Rs 3,137.78
Assessable Value Rs 3,16,915.78

 

Calculation of duty payable is as follows -       
  Duty Rate % Amount Rs Duty Rs
 (A) Assessable Value Rs   316,915.78  
 (B) Customs Duty 20   63,383.16
 (C) Sub-total for calculating CVD (A+B)   380,298.94  
 (D) CVD as % of C 16   60,847.83
 (E) Education cess of excise - 2% of 'D' 2   1,216.96
 (F) Sub-total for calculating Edu Cess (B+D+E)   125,447.95  
 (G) Education Cess of Customs (2% of 'F') 2   2,508.96
 (H) Sub-total for Special CVD (C+D+E+G)   444,872.69  
 (I) Special CVD (4% of 'H') 4   17,794.91
 (J) Total Duty Rs B+D+E+G     145,751.82
 (K) Total duty (rounded)     145,752.00

 

A manufacturer can avail Cenvat credit of duty as specified in columns D (i.e. CVD), E (education cess of excise) and I i.e. Spl CVD.

Q 5 Infotech Limited has imported a machine from Japan at an FOB cost of 50,000 yen (Japanese). The other expenses incurred are as follows: (i) Freight from Japan to Indian Port 5,000 yen. (ii) Insurance paid to insurer in India Rs. 2,500. (iii) Designing charges paid to consultancy firm in Japan 7,500 yen. (iv) M/s Infotech spent Rs. 25,000 in India for development work connected with the machine. (v) Transportation cost from Indian Port to factory Rs. 7,500. (vi) Central Government had announced exchange rate of 1 yen = Rs. 0.40 by Notification under Section 14(3) of the Customs Act, 1962. The exchange rate prevailing on that day in the market was 1 yen = Rs. 0.4052. (vii) M/s. Infotech made payment to the Bank based on an exchange rate of 1 yen = Rs. 0.4150. (viii) The Commission payable to the agent in India was at 5% of the FOB price in Indian Rupees. The rate of Customs duty is 20%. Similar goods are subject to 16% excise duty in India. Education cess on duty is 2%. Special CVD under section 3(5) of Customs Tariff Act is applicable. Clearly showing your workings to arrive at the total Assessable value in Rupees for purposes of Levy of Customs duty. How much Cenvat can be availed by importer, if he is manufacturer? [CA Final November 2002 - adapted]

Ans - Not solved, as it is exactly as per aforesaid example.

Q 6 M/s. Premium Industries Ltd., has imported a machine from Japan at an F.O.B. cost of 1,00,000 Yen (Japanese). The other expenses incurred were as follows : (i) Freight from Japan to Indian Port 10,000 Yen; (ii) Insurance paid to insurer in India Rs. 5,000; (iii) Designing Charges paid to consultancy firm in Japan 15,000 Yen; (iv) M/s Premium Industries Ltd. spent Rs. 50,000 in India for development work connected with the machine, (v) Transportation cost from Indian port to Factory Rs. 15,000; (vi) Central Government has announced exchange rate of 1 Yen = Re. 0.40 by notification under section 14(3). However the exchange rate prevailing in the market was 1 Yen = Re. 0.4052 (vii) M/s Premium Industries Ltd. made payment to the bank based on exchange rate of 1 Yen = Re. 0.4150, (viii) The commission payable to the agent in India was @ 5% of F.O.B. price in Indian Rupees. - . - The rate of custom duty is 20%. Similar goods are subject to 16% excise in India. Education cess on duty is 2%. Special CVD under section 3(5) of Customs Tariff Act is applicable. Find the custom duty and other duties payable. How much Cenvat can be availed by importer, if he is manufacturer? [ICWA Inter June 2000 adapted]

Ans - Not solved, as it is exactly as per aforesaid example.

Q 7 Calculate the total Customs duty liability from the following data: - Product imported from France : Gears * C.I.F. value in French Franc : 20,000 * Exchange rate : 1 FF = Rs. 6.25. * Additional Information : (1) C.I.F. value includes Air Freight of 2,000 FF’s and Insurance of 200 FF. (2) Basic Customs duty : 20% (3) Excise duty chargeable on similar goods in India is 16% as per tariff rate. However, as per an exemption notification the effective rate is 8%. (4) Education cess on duty – 2%. (5) Special CVD under section 3(5) of Customs Tariff Act is applicable. [ICWA Inter December 2000 adapted] How much Cenvat can be availed by importer, if he is manufacturer?.

Ans - Not solved, since similar.

Q 8 ‘A’ imports by air from USA a Gear cutting machine complete with accessories and spares. Its HS classification is 84.6140 and Value US $ f.o.b. 20,000. - - Other relevant date/information: (1) At the request of importer, US $ 1,000 have been incurred for improving the design, etc. of machine, but is not reflected in the invoice, but will be paid by the party. (2) Freight - US $ 6,000. (3) Goods are insured but premium is not shown/available in invoice. (4) Commission to be paid to local agent in India Rs. 4,500. (5) Freight and insurance from airport to factory is Rs. 4,500. (6) Exchange rate is US $ 1 = Rs. 45. (7) Duties of Customs : Basic – 20% CVD – 16% Education cess on duty – 2%. Special CVD under section 3(5) of Customs Tariff Act is applicable. - - Compute (i) Assessable value (ii) Customs duty. How much Cenvat can be availed by importer, if he is manufacturer? [ICWA Inter December 2002 adapted]

Answer 8 (i)  Computation of Assessable Value

FOB Value of Machine US $  $ 20,000    
Add: Expenditure for improving design $ 1,000    
Add - Freight limited to 20% of FOB [Rule 9 (2)] $ 4,000    
Insurance @ 1.125% of FOB [Rule 9(2)c(iii)] $ 225    

Sub-Total   

$ 25,225    
Sub-Total In Rs @ Rs 45 per Rupee     Rs 11,35,125
Add -  Agents Commission [Rule 9(1)(i)]     Rs        4,500
Total CIF Value     Rs 11,39,625
Add – Landing charges 1% of CIF     Rs      11,396
Assessable Value     Rs 11,51,021

Duty payable will be as follows –

Calculation of duty payable is as follows -       
  Duty Rate % Amount Rs Duty Rs
 (A) Assessable Value Rs   1,151,021.00  
 (B) Customs Duty 20   230,204.20
 (C) Sub-total for calculating CVD (A+B)   1,381,225.20  
 (D) CVD as % of C 16   220,996.03
 (E) Education cess of excise - 2% of 'D' 2   4,419.92
 (F) Sub-total for calculating Edu Cess (B+D+E)   455,620.15  
 (G) Education Cess of Customs (2% of 'F') 2   9,112.40
 (H) Sub-total for Special CVD (C+D+E+G)   1,615,753.55  
 (I) Special CVD (4% of 'H') 4   64,630.14
 (J) Total Duty Rs B+D+E+G     529,362.69
 (K) Total duty (rounded)     529,363.00

A manufacturer can avail Cenvat credit of duty as specified in columns D (i.e. CVD), E (education cess of excise) and I i.e. Spl CVD.

Q 9 - Determine the total Customs Duty payable from the following data - Quantity imported : 100 MTs,  FOB value : Swiss Franc : 10000, AIR Freight : Swiss Franc : 2500, Insurance : Data not available, Exchange rate : 1 Swiss Franc = Rs. 34, Rate of BCD 30%, Rate of Cenvat under First Schedule to CETA : 16%, Rate of SED under Second Schedule to CETA : 16%, Rate of AED (GSI) under Additional Duties of Excise (GSI) Act : Rs. 10/kg, Rate of NCCD 1%, Education cess – 2% of duty. Special CVD under section 3(5) of Customs Tariff Act is applicable. How much Cenvat can be availed by importer, if he is manufacturer? [ICWA Inter June 2003 adapted]

Answer 9 FOB price is 10,000.00 Swiss Francs. Since air freight is more than 20% of FOB, freight is required to be limited to 20% of FOB i.e. 2.000 SF (Swiss Francs). Since insurance data is not available, insurance cost is to be taken @ 1.125% on FOB, i.e. 112.50 SF. Hence, CIF value is 12,112.50 SF (FOB 10,000 + Freight 2,000 + Insurance 112.50 SF). Add landing charges of 1% of CIF i.e. 121.13. Hence, ‘Assessable Value’ or ‘Customs Value’ is 12,233.63 SF i.e. Rs 4,15,943.25.

The duty calculations are as follows –

Calculation of duty payable is as follows -       
  Duty Rate % Amount Rs Duty Rs
 (A) Assessable Value Rs   415,943.25  
 (B) Customs Duty 30   124,782.98
 (B1) NCCD 1% 1   4,159.43
 (C) Sub-total for calculating CVD (A+B)   544,885.66  
 (D) CVD as % of C 32   174,363.41
 (E) Education cess of excise - 2% of 'D' 2   3,487.27
 (E1) AED (GSI) @ Rs 10 per Kg     1,000,000.00
 (F) Sub-total for calculating Edu Cess (B+D+E+E1)   1,306,793.09  
 (G) Education Cess of Customs (2% of 'F') 2   26,135.86
 (H) Sub-total for Special CVD (C+D+E+E1+G)   1,748,872.20  
 (I) Special CVD (4% of 'H') 4   69,954.89
 (J) Total Duty Rs B+D+E+G     1,402,883.84
 (K) Total duty (rounded)     1,402,884.00

 

A manufacturer/importer can avail Cenvat credit of duty as specified in columns D (i.e. CVD) and G i.e. Spl CVD.

Notes – (1) Basic Excise Duty (Cenvat) is 16% and Special Excise Duty (SED) is 16%. Hence, CVD, which is equal to excise duty will be 32%. In addition 2% education cess is payable. Hence, total CVD is 32.64% (2) As per Notification No. 77/2003-Cus dated 14-5-2003, NCCD of excise is not required to be considered while calculating CVD.

Q 10 - Determine the assessable value and customs duty amount from the following data: # Name of the raw material—X  # FOB value – Euro 1 million # Ocean freight – Actual data not available # Ocean Insurance – Actual data not available # Freight from sea port to godown paid in India Rs. 10,000 # Transit insurance in India – Rs. 2,000 # Selling commission paid to agent in India – 5% # Royalty on manufacture and sale of final product payable to foreign collaborator – 5% # Interest payable on raw material imported at 180 days credit (on FOB value) 12% p.a. # Dividend paid to the foreign supplier of raw material on their equity participation for the year 2001-02  -  Rs. 2 per share on 1 million shares of face value Rs. 10/ share. # Importer supplied design and drawings worth Euro 10,000 to the foreign raw material supplier. # Landing charges as per Customs provisions # Customs duty rates : BCD - 20%, CVD - 16%, Education Cess on duty – 2%. Special CVD under section 3(5) of Customs Tariff Act is applicable. # Exchange rate: 1 Euro = Rs. 42. How much Cenvat can be availed by importer, if he is manufacturer? [ICWA June 2002 adapted]

Answer 10 – Since ocean freight is not available, it has to be taken at 20% of FOB. Insurance will have to be taken @ 1.125% of FOB Value.

Royalty on manufacture and sale of final products payable to foreign collaborators has no relation to goods imported. Hence, it is not includible in Assessable Value for customs. Similarly, dividend paid to foreign supplier has no relation with supply of raw materials. It is not includible in Assessable Value.

Interest payable for credit is not includible in assessable value for customs purposes, as it is not part of ‘transaction value’.

Freight from seaport to godown and transit insurance in India are post-importation costs and are not includible.

It is assumed that selling commission to selling agent in India is payable on basis of CIF Value of goods including cost of drawings supplied by buyer.

As per rule 9(1)(b)(iv) of Customs Valuation Rules, cost of engineering drawings is includible only if work was undertaken outside India. Since, payment has been made in Euro, it is assumed that the design and drawing work was done outside India.

Landing charges will be 1% of CIF Value, as per Customs Valuation Rules.

Hence, calculation of customs duty will be as follows –

(A) Value of goods in Euro

10,00,000 Euro

 

(B) Add – Freight @ 20% of FOB

2,00,000 Euro

 

(C) Add – Insurance @ 1.125% of FOB

11,250 Euro

 

(D) Total CIF Value (A+B+C)

 

12,11,250 Euro

(E) Add designing and drawing charges

 

10,000 Euro

(F) Total CIF Value

 

12,21,250 Euro

(G) CIF Value in Rupees @ Rs 42.00

 

5,12,92,500.00 Rs

(H) Local Agency Commission @ 5%

 

25,64,625.00 Rs

(I) Total Value

 

5,38,57,125 Rs

(J) Add – Landing Charges @ 1% of ‘I’

 

5,38,571.25 Rs

(J) Assessable Value (I+J)

 

5,43,95,696.25 Rs

 

Calculation of duty payable is as follows -       
  Duty Rate % Amount Rs Duty Rs
 (A) Assessable Value Rs   54,395,696.25  
 (B) Customs Duty 20   10,879,139.25
 (C) Sub-total for calculating CVD (A+B)   65,274,835.50  
 (D) CVD as % of C 16   10,443,973.68
 (E) Education cess of excise - 2% of 'D' 2   208,879.47
 (F) Sub-total for calculating Edu Cess (B+D+E)   21,531,992.40  
 (G) Education Cess of Customs (2% of 'F') 2   430,639.85
 (H) Sub-total for Special CVD (C+D+E+G)   76,358,328.50  
 (I) Special CVD (4% of 'H') 4   3,054,333.14
 (J) Total Duty Rs B+D+E+G     25,016,965.39
 (K) Total duty (rounded)     25,016,965.00

 

A manufacturer can avail Cenvat credit of duty as specified in columns D (i.e. CVD), E (education cess of excise) and I i.e. Spl CVD.

 

Back Up Next